Criminal Appeals

Criminal Appeals in New Mexico

At Mitchell Law Offices, LLC, we know that a conviction, harsh sentence, and/or a improper judicial decision can feel like the end of the road—but it isn’t. Under certain circumstances, New Mexico law gives you the chance to challenge those outcomes through the appeals process. An appeal is an opportunity to have a higher court review what happened below and decide whether errors or violations of your rights changed the course of your case. Appeals can also arise even before trial begins. For example, when a judge orders that you be held in custody without bond in a preventative detention hearing. These rulings carry immediate, life-changing consequences, and they too can be appealed.

The appellate process is unforgiving. Deadlines are short, the rules are strict, and every filing must be done with precision. Whether you are appealing a conviction, a sentence, or a pre-trial detention order, success depends on an attorney who understands the unique procedures of New Mexico’s appellate courts. At Mitchell Law Offices, your appeals attorney, Aaron Mitchell, brings sharp legal analysis and relentless advocacy to every appeal, ensuring that no error goes unchallenged and no opportunity for relief is missed.

What a Criminal Appeal Is—and What It Is Not

– Procedural errors at trial
– Improper admission or exclusion of evidence
– Misapplication of legal principles
– Juror misconduct
– Ineffective assistance of counsel
– Insufficient evidence to support the conviction
– Newly discovered evidence

You cannot appeal simply because you disagree with the outcome—you must identify valid legal grounds. Mitchell Law Offices’ appellate attorney, Aaron Mitchell, can help you decide whether you have grounds for an appeal and whether an appeal is right for you under your circumstances.

Types of Criminal Appeals in New Mexico

Who Hears the Appeal:
• All appeals from magistrate court are heard in the district court.
Deadline:
• A Notice of Appeal must be filed within 15 days of the final judgment or order (Rule 6-703 NMRA).
Type of Appeal:
• Magistrate appeals are subject to de novo review, meaning the district court considers the case as if it was being heard for the first time.
Pre-Adjudication (Interlocutory) Appeals:
• In rare cases, you may seek immediate review of a magistrate ruling before trial (e.g., certain suppression rulings or denial of speedy trial rights).
• These require district court approval.

Who Hears the Appeal?

  • Non-Record Cases:
    • Non-record case appeals from the Albuquerque Metro Court are reviewed de novo by the 2nd Judicial District Court.
    • A Notice of Appeal must be filed within 15 days of the judgment or final order (Rule 7-703 NMRA).
  • Record Cases:
    • Record case appeals from the Albuquerque Metro Court are reviewed by the Court of Appeals.
    • A Notice of Appeal must be filed within 15 days of the judgment or final order (Rule 7-703 NMRA).

Who Hears the Appeal:
• Appeals from district court cases go to the New Mexico Court of Appeals, unless the case involves life imprisonment or the death penalty, in which case it goes directly to the New Mexico Supreme Court.
• A Notice of Appeal must be filed within 30 days of the final judgment or sentencing order (Rule 12-201 NMRA).
• Type of Appeal:
◦ These appeals are limited to the trial record. Your appellate lawyer submits written briefs, and in some cases, will present oral argument, to argue that legal errors that occurred in the case while in the trial court require reversal and/or modification from the Court of Appeals.
• Scope of Review:
◦ Whether legal errors occurred during a hearing, trial, or sentencing;
◦ Whether the evidence was sufficient to support the conviction or a legal decision;
◦ Whether the trial court properly applied laws; and
◦ Whether constitutional violations occurred.
• Possible Outcomes:
◦ Affirmance:
▪ The appellate court upholds the conviction and sentence;
◦ Reversal:
▪ The appellate court overturns the conviction or sentence; or
◦ Remand:
▪ The appellate court sends the case back to the trial court for a new trial, new sentencing, or other proceedings.

Criminal Appeal Image

Appeals Involving Conditions of Release

– If the State seeks preventative detention (pretrial detention without bond) under N.M. Const. art. II, § 13 and Rule 5-409 NMRA, and the district court orders detention, you may appeal.
– Deadline: A Notice of Appeal must be filed within 10 days of the detention order (Rule 12-204(C) NMRA).
– Reviewing Court: Appeals are heard by the New Mexico Court of Appeals.
– Scope: The appellate court reviews whether the State proved by clear and convincing evidence that no release conditions could reasonably assure public safety.

– If the district court revokes your bond or modifies your release conditions in a way that unlawfully restricts your liberty, you may appeal under Rule 5-405 NMRA.
– Deadline: A Notice of Appeal must be filed within 10 days of the order.
– These appeals are expedited given the liberty interests at stake.

The Criminal Appeal Process from District Court to Court of Appeals

The Criminal Appeal Process in New Mexico

1. Notice of Appeal

The process begins with filing a Notice of Appeal. In New Mexico, the deadline depends on the type of case:
◦ District Court criminal cases: 30 days from the entry of the final judgment or sentence.
◦ Pretrial detention or bond decisions: 10 days from the order.
Missing these deadlines almost always results in losing the right to appeal.

2. Docketing Statement or Statement of Issues

Once the Notice of Appeal is filed, the case must be docketed in the appellate court. In the Court of Appeals, the appellant files a Docketing Statement within 30 days. In the Supreme Court, the appellant files a Statement of the Issues. These documents summarize the case, identify the errors being challenged, and explain how those issues were preserved during trial.

3. Record on Appeal

The appellate court does not hear new testimony or retry the case. Instead, it reviews the record on appeal, which includes the trial transcript, pleadings, and exhibits from the lower court. This record is compiled and transmitted so the appellate court can evaluate whether legal mistakes were made.

4. Written Briefs

Written arguments are the heart of an appeal. The appellant files a Brief in Chief, setting out the legal errors and explaining why the lower court’s ruling should be reversed or modified. The State then files an Answer Brief, and the appellant may file a Reply Brief. Deadlines are set by the appellate court, typically 30–45 days depending on the calendar assignment.

5. Oral Argument (If Granted)

In some cases, the appellate court allows oral argument. This gives the attorneys an opportunity to appear before a panel of judges, highlight key issues, and answer questions. However, many appeals are decided solely on the written briefs.

6. Decision of the Appellate Court

After reviewing the briefs and the record, the appellate court issues its decision. The court may:
◦ Affirm: Agree with the lower court and uphold the judgment.
◦ Reverse: Overturn the judgment or sentence.
◦ Remand: Send the case back to the trial court for a new trial, hearing, or resentencing.
◦ Modify: In some cases, the appellate court may alter the ruling without requiring a new trial.

The Magistrate Court Appeal Process in New Mexico District Court

In New Mexico, any party wishing to appeal a final judgment or order from magistrate court or metropolitan court must file a Notice of Appeal with the district court within 15 days of the judgment being entered. This deadline is strict—if it is missed, the right to appeal is lost.

Appeals from magistrate court are not limited to reviewing the record for legal errors. Instead, the case is heard de novo in district court. This means the case starts over completely, as if the magistrate trial never occurred. The district court judge considers the evidence and testimony anew, and both sides may present additional witnesses and exhibits.

While the district court obtains the magistrate court’s file, the appeal does not depend solely on what happened in magistrate court. The retrial is a fresh proceeding, and new arguments and evidence may be introduced.

The appeal functions as a full trial. The prosecution must again present its case, and the defense has the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses, challenge evidence, and assert all available defenses. Because it is a new trial, procedural and evidentiary objections can be raised directly before the district court.

5. District Court’s Decision

What appeals we do not do

1. Habeas Corpus Petition
2. Appeals from the Federal Court
3. Civil Appeals
4. Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims

 

Why You Need Mitchell Law Offices on Your Appeal

Not every trial lawyer is built for appellate battles. Appeals are a different arena—where precision, strategy, and legal firepower matter more than theatrics. Winning on appeal requires razor-sharp legal writing, mastery of complex procedural rules, and the ability to uncover errors that others overlook in the trial record. That’s where Mitchell Law Offices stands apart.

Our firm doesn’t just “handle” appeals—we attack them with the intensity and thoroughness your case deserves. We take on the full spectrum of criminal appeals in New Mexico, including emergency interlocutory appeals, challenges to preventative detention and bond revocations, and post-adjudication appeals of final judgments. Each case is dissected line by line, ruling by ruling, to expose the weaknesses in the State’s position and position you for the best possible outcome.

At Mitchell Law Offices, protecting your rights isn’t just part of the process—it’s the mission. We know what’s at stake: your freedom, your record, and your future. When you choose Aaron Mitchell and his team, you’re choosing a law office that refuses to accept injustice and is relentless in fighting to overturn wrongful convictions and unfair sentences.

Take Action Immediately

Time is everything in the appeals process. In New Mexico, strict deadlines govern when and how you can challenge a conviction, sentence, or detention order. Miss the filing date, and your right to appeal is gone forever. That’s why hiring a dedicated criminal appeals attorney right away is absolutely vital.

At Mitchell Law Offices, we move fast. The moment you retain, we begin gathering trial records, scrutinizing every ruling, and isolating the legal errors that could reverse or reduce the outcome of your case. Whether the mistake occurred before trial, during trial, at sentencing, or in a pretrial detention hearing, we are prepared to act decisively to protect your future.

Do not delay. For every day you wait, you exclude a day that your attorney can work on your case, and the State is already moving forward to preserve its case against you. Secure your ability to appeal now by putting Mitchell Law Offices in your corner—we don’t just defend appeals, we fight to undo injustice.

Contact Mitchell Law Offices, LLC today to discuss your options for a criminal appeal.

Contact Us